1
00:00:12,255 --> 00:00:20,959
Niira Radia:  Venu, hi. Sorry I... you called.
M.K. Venu:  Yeah, Niira I, you know, there's this interesting story I saw in Business Standard.

2
00:00:20,959 --> 00:00:25,055
Niira Radia:  Uh huh.
M.K. Venu:  About how, you know this Defence Offset Policy.

3
00:00:25,055 --> 00:00:39,392
Niira Radia:  Uh huh.
M.K. Venu:  You know Defence Offset Policy is what, the government you know, is, you know, government is going to buy about hundred and fifty thousand crore worth of defence equipment over the next (not clear) phase, five years.

4
00:00:39,392 --> 00:00:44,000
Niira Radia:  Yeah, yeah. I’m aware of it.
M.K. Venu:  Now under the Offset Policy TATAs and L&Ts and Mahindras-

5
00:00:44,000 --> 00:00:53,728
Niira Radia:  Yeah, I’ve seen that.
M.K. Venu : - are tying up with foreign defence manufacturers about 30% of that will have to be purchased from India or will have to invested in India in equipment.

6
00:00:53,728 --> 00:01:00,384
Niira Radia:  Correct.
M.K. Venu:  So that creates an opportunity of fifty thousand crore over next five years -

7
00:01:00,384 --> 00:01:06,784
Niira Radia:  Hmm hmm. 
M.K. Venu: For the work to be done in India hmm so that’s the offset policy.

8
00:01:06,784 --> 00:01:18,816
Niira Radia:  Hmm hmm.
M.K. Venu:  Now, do you think if we did a television story..umm..on how the Offset Policy will work out at the joint venture level and the BS (Business Standard) story talks about the JVP (not audible) you know.

9
00:01:18,816 --> 00:01:29,312
Niira Radia:  Yeah, yeah.
M.K. Venu:  So, people will talk some, say TATAs, Mahindras and of course the L&T? We just want to build a comprehensive story you know. You think it will be possible?

10
00:01:29,312 --> 00:01:43,648
Niira Radia:  Yeah, maybe, I’ll get one or two, whoever are they, maybe the one or two who have done the Swarovski deal, or maybe one of them.
M.K. Venu:  Yeah? Because the TATA are speaking to  Israel, the leading Israeli company you know -

11
00:01:43,648 --> 00:01:57,216
Niira Radia:  Yeah, yeah.
M.K. Venu: - French company and all you know. Because this is interesting even from the market perspective, because each of these deals will have an upside, topline upside you know of 20-30%, for that company, you know, which may be listed in the market also no.

12
00:01:57,216 --> 00:02:09,502
Niira Radia:  Hmm, hmm, hmm, hmmm. Yeah, let me know when you’re planning to do it, I’ll have a word.
M.K. Venu:  Yeah, hmm. And one more thing Nira, just a small favour.

13
00:02:09,502 --> 00:02:29,983
Niira Radia:  Uh huh.
M.K. Venu:  (clears throat) You know we (clears throat) there’s a, you know there’s a, I mean I’m saying this, because I, I’m responsible for...you know there’s a girl who's joined, very bright girl who joined ET Now, she used to be in CNBC for three four years and she was the best performer, then she got married and went off to US and now she has returned and joined ET.

14
00:02:29,983 --> 00:02:42,271
M.K.Venu: Her name is Rohini Singh. So, I had actually brought her in into ET Now you know.  She’s coming after about a year, spending a year in the US with her husband.

15
00:02:42,271 --> 00:02:59,679
M.K. Venu: Now, but she has, of course she has network of contacts and just wanted her to be introduced to some people in your system.  So, I want to, next time I, can she come and meet you, generally, you know.

16
00:02:59,679 --> 00:03:13,503
Niira Radia:  Ok. So, Venu this week I’m going, I’m going to Bombay, I’ll be back on Thursday.
M.K. Venu:  If actually you know, she’ll be covering policy you know,  finance ministry, uh you know and some other key policies.

17
00:03:13,503 --> 00:03:27,839
M.K. Venu: So, since, uh, the people that you handle no, the TATAs and others they have always have their, all their activities have some policy implications <i>na</i>?  So, I just wanted you to help her out on the policy side of it, that’s all.

18
00:03:27,839 --> 00:03:41,664
Niira Radia:  Yeah, yeah, sure, sure. No problem. No problem. Anytime, once I’m back then we meet on Thursday or Friday, no, no problem. I’ll be happy to help.
M.K. Venu: Because she, she joined last week and she done good, she’s done good, interesting stories also in the meanwhile.

19
00:03:41,664 --> 00:03:47,807
Niira Radia:  Uh huh, what has she done?
M.K. Venu:  Ah, Yeah. She was in CNBC for three and a half four years. Yeah.

20
00:03:47,807 --> 00:03:58,304
Niira Radia:  Uh huh, uh huh, uh huh. How are things on the Gas side?
M.K. Venu:  On the Gas side? On the Gas side Murli Deora statement came <i>na</i> that -

21
00:03:58,304 --> 00:04:01,631
Niira Radia:  Yeah, yeah yeah yeah.
M.K. Venu: - government will protect its interest, you know.

22
00:04:01,631 --> 00:04:05,472
Niira Radia:  Yeah, Sunil Jain has done his bit to it today.
M.K. Venu:  What, what has he written?

23
00:04:05,472 --> 00:04:15,199
Niira Radia:  No, nothing. Basically he is talking absolute nonsense. Why, why make RIL’s balance sheet fatter.And what about the power sector which desperately needs gas.

24
00:04:15,199 --> 00:04:28,000
Niira Radia: I mean, who’s saying that it’s not coming to them you know. And the question is that are they going to pass the profits they make to the consumer? Of course they're not. The PPA agreements are defined tariffs, you know.
M.K. Venu:  Yeah, but I thought fertilizer precedes power no?

25
00:04:28,000 --> 00:04:33,119
Niira Radia:  Yeah. And fertilizer is that important for the common man in any case you know. 
M.K. Venu:  Yeah, yeah.

26
00:04:33,119 --> 00:04:45,152
Niira Radia: In any case there are existing power plants also. These are all PPA based, uh, uh, tariff. Nobody is going to pass the benefit back.
M.K. Venu:  Yeah, yeah, yeah. That’s all bulk you know.

27
00:04:45,152 --> 00:05:01,535
Niira Radia:  Yeah, he is all talking out of his hat, so. Uh, you’re doing your piece, no, Venu?
M.K. Venu:  Yeah, I’m writing something, yeah yeah. Basically I am looking at a larger piece on, on, a bit like what, uh Vir Sanghvi actually pre-empted me a little (laughs). 
Niira Radia:  Hmm, hmm.

28
00:05:01,535 --> 00:05:16,639
M.K. Venu: There was a line I was going to take you know, that in critical resources there should be, uh, national policy. And national policy should, should, obviously supersede. I would, I was actually planning a strong piece, we're not a banana republic you know -

29
00:05:16,639 --> 00:05:23,807
Niira Radia:  Correct.
M.K. Venu: - where some, uh, bloody company is deciding, government policy you know, in Africa for instance.

30
00:05:23,807 --> 00:05:28,160
Niira Radia:  Correct.
M.K. Venu:  So, so, you know. Anyway I’ll still write it.

31
00:05:28,160 --> 00:05:32,000
Niira Radia:  Yeah, but you know-
M.K. Venu:  (cuts in) You saw Vir Sanghvi’s piece <i>na</i>?

32
00:05:32,000 --> 00:05:39,679
Niira Radia:  Yeah, I saw it yesterday. But you know, I guess I think he’s gone more into the sort of corruption and ministers.
M.K. Venu:  No, no, I’m not into that. Yeah, yeah, I’ll be writing -

33
00:05:39,679 --> 00:05:55,040
Niira Radia:  He overshot it a bit, yeah.
M.K. Venu:  Yeah, yeah. I wanted to also, this, Baijal give a statement that he wanted to auctioning should be done on a, on a, wholesome basis not, you know. I wanted to understand that argument also.

34
00:05:55,040 --> 00:06:00,415
Niira Radia:  Yeah. Ok. You want to talk to him? You got his mobile, no?
M.K. Venu:  Yeah. Yeah. I’ll speak to him. Yeah, yeah.

35
00:06:00,415 --> 00:06:14,496
Niira Radia:  Yeah, yeah. And I also think if you look at it, the question is you’re right, it should be the national policy and not some tribunal High Court judges deciding what it is <i>na</i>, who don’t understand what is economics <i>na</i>.
M.K. Venu:  Yeah. Nira, can you tell one of your researchers  -

36
00:06:14,496 --> 00:06:26,015
Niira Radia:  Uh huh.
M.K. Venu: - to give me just one, two three figures. I just need two three big figures, which is just total value of spectrum 
Niira Radia:  Mmhmm.
M.K. Venu: - potential value, you know.

37
00:06:26,015 --> 00:06:48,544
Niira Radia:  In both 2G, 3G space?
M.K. Venu:  Yeah, yeah. Total value, potential value, total potential value of spectrum that exists, that is going to be auctioned and potential value of the, uh uh, coal reserves uh...or the total value of coal reserves, gas and iron ore you know.

38
00:06:48,544 --> 00:06:58,272
M.K. Venu: If these four things I get then I can consolidate them, you know, into a big figure, and I’ll say that these, I mean, are the, are the, national wealth you know.

39
00:06:58,272 --> 00:07:05,951
Niira Radia:  Umm, ok. I’ll get that, I’ll get, I’ll get it put on your email today?
M.K. Venu:  Yeah, yeah. It makes sense <i>na</i>?

40
00:07:05,951 --> 00:07:09,791
Niira Radia:  Yeah, yeah, makes lot of sense. But you know it’s a huge figure. 
M.K. Venu:  I know, but -

41
00:07:09,791 --> 00:07:19,264
Niira: Radia: In the case of coal you know, we, we, we haven’t even touched the surface you know.
M.K. Venu:  Yeah, I believe coal reserves are some two hundred billion tonnes or something no?

42
00:07:19,264 --> 00:07:24,384
Niira Radia:  Yeah, that’s what. But we haven’t even started to, started to mine further.
M.K. Venu:  Umm, hmm.

43
00:07:24,384 --> 00:07:33,855
Niira Radia: (Inaudible)...Yeah, yeah, but I’ll get the figures to you.

44
00:07:33,855 --> 00:07:47,936
M.K. Venu:  Basically the point that I want to make is that if this is the value of, if this is national wealth, which needs to be harnessed to the optimal in the national interest, so the competition should not fall, uh, prey to crony capitalism you know.

45
00:07:47,936 --> 00:07:50,496
Niira Radia:  Right.
M.K. Venu:  Basically that’s the point I want to make you know.

46
00:07:50,496 --> 00:08:02,272
Niira Radia:  Right. Right. Right. And what on the judgment, Venu? Uh, sorry to, you know, ask.
M.K. Venu:  No, no. As for the judgment, I will, I will focus. Infact I will start with the judgement only you know.

47
00:08:02,272 --> 00:08:23,821
Niira Radia:  Mmmhmm. Mmmhmm.
M.K. Venu:  So uh. In fact I’m trying to speak to one or two constitutional experts, in general terms on whether, you know. Somebody like Shanti Bhushan or you know. So, on my own what are the constitutional provisions which might apply to this, uh, to this you know to a case like this -
(Tape ends abruptly)

